Patrol 4x4 - Nissan Patrol Forum banner

Do you support a 'founding nations voice' in parliament

  • Yes

    Votes: 1 4.8%
  • No

    Votes: 20 95.2%
1221 - 1240 of 1337 Posts

· The Googlest, Apparently!
NP300
Joined
·
16,365 Posts
I also saw that, and it was the final decider for me, it’ll be a no from me on the referendum.

There has been too much radical activist talk by many in the indigenous community, echoed by the Greens, about indigenous truth commissions, treaties, reparations and indigenous sovereignty to leave it all up to the parliament where deals (identity politics) are done in order to secure passage of bills.

I think it is entirely reasonable for voters to ask voice proponents, starting with Albo, to set out the basic structure of this new political institution and how it will work to alleviate indigenous disadvantage, and prevent take over of the national identity, before being expected to permanently enshrine it in the Constitution.

The way to avoid an information vacuum defaulting to identity politics is to have an informed and open debate about the details of what is being proposed.

Trouble is, the lefty cancel culture muppets who think that anything right of centre is an anachronism of the past that needs to be exterminated, thus who only understand identity politics, will be overjoyed and out in droves come voting day.

So it will pass and Albo will get his way.

The way I see the world going these days I’m actually glad that there is less days in front of me than behind me, the world is fast becoming one truly fcuked up place.
 

· Premium Member
Nuffin now
Joined
·
30,315 Posts
What plisses me off is, they already have the ability for a greater voice, they are just too forking lazy to get off their arses and back someone from their own culture. Look at how they they treat Warren Mundine and Jacinta Price when they speak up against what they call "sit down money" and for the lazy sods to get out and work for what they want! :rolleyes: 🤬

The ones that have made something of their lives are hounded for hand outs and if the money isn't coming, then they want to belt the living out of that person. 48yrs ago I raced against an aboriginal bloke from Moree, he hell down two jobs, had a nice home and beautiful family and was respected by the "white" community, why, because he got off his arse and worked for what he had. My parents have a friend that is also a part blood but he refused to take advantage of easy money by not ticking the box that asked the question of race and also instilled that thinking in his kids. 👏

Politicians from all sides are too quick too jump on the "bandwagon" of these want everything handed to them but won't do anything to get it themselves, except roam the streets screaming we are hard done by, well fork them and their backers. 🖕

Don't care if this post upsets anyone because the truth hurts and I'm in no mood for taking :poop: at the moment. :rolleyes:

Foo
 

· Premium Member
Nuffin now
Joined
·
30,315 Posts
New Year’s Eve fireworks in Sydney will have a ‘voice’ theme.
Of course it would, the forking try hard's will infiltrate anything to make noise, lookout Australia Day. 🤬🤬

Foo
 

· I Have Imaginary Friends
Patrol Hybrid.
Joined
·
23,157 Posts
Of course it would, the forking try hard's will infiltrate anything to make noise, lookout Australia Day. 🤬🤬

Foo
Channel 10 is refusing to call it Australia Day, or recognise it. Clover Moore is behind the fireworks display.
How’s you BP now? 🤔
 
  • Angry
Reactions: Foo

· Premium Member
Nuffin now
Joined
·
30,315 Posts
Channel 10 is refusing to call it Australia Day, or recognise it. Clover Moore is behind the fireworks display.
How’s you BP now? 🤔
Don't forking ask, my head space is toxic at the moment. 🤬 Plus I don't have my heart rate strap on and probably a good thing because some hero's in Landrover thought it was fun to sing out abuse at me. Was hoping to find them but they must have left the Island. Forking cowards! 🤬

Foo
 
  • Like
Reactions: rgren2

· Premium Member
Nuffin now
Joined
·
30,315 Posts
A reply to a mate about the levels of Government here, when he said that the Federal should be dissolved but I want the State level gone. 🙂

Graeme, then lets get rid of the top tear of double management in the Federal and totally disband State. Them make every single Politician to swear an oath of honesty when/if they are found out, then they are prosecuted to the same degree as in a perjury case. 🤔

No level of Government should have a media spin section or media advisors, nor outside consultancy firms. Employ people that know the jobs inside out and no Politician that has been in office can sit on any advisory board for companies with direct access to Government Ministers. 😤

Any appointment for overseas Ambassador, can not be given by heads of Governments but by an independent panel of High Court Judges that have proven commonsense and wisdom. ;)

Foo
 
  • Like
Reactions: grumpyone

· Administrator
Y2KGUII ZD Wgn
Joined
·
57,481 Posts
Discussion Starter · #1,230 · (Edited)
Is he actually trying to set this up for failure?????? Honestly I don't know anyone who will vote yes on the current info out there. The below figures are a little mystifying as they are growing annually???? but take it as of 2021 it is 3.2% of the population. Not forgetting history but accepting it all happened in another time and we move on, HOW MUCH OF A VOICE IS IT?


Population
In Australia, 812,000 people identified as Aboriginal and/or Torres Strait Islander in the 2021 Census of Population and Housing. Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people represented 3.2% of the population. This was up from 2.8% in 2016, and 2.5% in 2011.
Of the 812,000 people who identified as being of Aboriginal and/or Torres Strait Islander origin:
  • 91.4% identified as Aboriginal
  • 4.2% identified as Torres Strait Islander
  • 4.4% identified as both Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander.

EDIT: Latest number I could find for taxpayers in AU was from 2015/16 where 13.5M tax returns were lodged, surely those taxpayers would like to see/hear about where/what and effectiveness of the billions already being spent.

Estimated expenditure per person in 2012-13 was $43,449 for Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Australians, compared with $20,900 for other Australians (a ratio of 2.08 to 1 — an increase from a ratio of 1.93 to 1 in 2008-09).
 

· Rogue
22' Ranger Raptor V6TT
Joined
·
20,720 Posts
I need to know some more general points of the setup before I can support a change.

Who will appoint/elect the voice representative for such a broad range of people? How do those they represent, keep them accountable? How do all indigenous nations/clans get equal/proportional representation? What is the support structure of the voice representative (office size, location, staffing, travel budget, etc)? What federal scope does the voice have to be part of?
 
  • Like
Reactions: grumpyone

· Administrator
Y2KGUII ZD Wgn
Joined
·
57,481 Posts
Discussion Starter · #1,232 ·
I need to know some more general points of the setup before I can support a change.

Who will appoint/elect the voice representative for such a broad range of people? How do those they represent, keep them accountable? How do all indigenous nations/clans get equal/proportional representation? What is the support structure of the voice representative (office size, location, staffing, travel budget, etc)? What federal scope does the voice have to be part of?
Ed Bloody Zackery.
 

· Administrator
Y2KGUII ZD Wgn
Joined
·
57,481 Posts
Discussion Starter · #1,237 ·
Oh! if only I had a twitter account (but it ain't gonna happen) I'd answer "Yes, for bloody sure I am, get over it you ****ing moron".
 

· Administrator
Y2KGUII ZD Wgn
Joined
·
57,481 Posts
Discussion Starter · #1,238 ·
This just came to my attention. Some good comments about parenting and earlier days before dogooders.
 

· Administrator
Y2KGUII ZD Wgn
Joined
·
57,481 Posts
Discussion Starter · #1,239 ·
OMG, one would hope that voters, regardless of their leanings, vote in the upcoming NSW election on current issues, not something that happened at a fancy dress party over 20 years ago.
 
1221 - 1240 of 1337 Posts
Top