Patrol 4x4 - Nissan Patrol Forum banner

GU Ute : Rear Coils vs Rear Leaf

1 reading
18K views 13 replies 13 participants last post by  MQTray  
#1 ·
rear coil guys, please list your pros' & cons...
rear leaf guys, please list your pros' and cons..


ive had a thought about upgrading my shorty, and would be wanting to go to a GU,
with a TD42t/TD42Ti depending on what i can get my hands on.

how ever, i can only seem to find rear leaf's, and rear coil's are as rare as hens teeth with a massive price tag.

im NOT after alot of flex, i would like a bit, but dont need a monster flex.


the plans would be a well built and capable real remote tourer. will have a custom steel canopy on the back, water tank, long range fuel tank and 2 spares on the rear. will also be use from time to time to tow a 900kg camper, my 1250kg boat and the parents 1300kg caravan.

tips in mind would be the simpson, camerons corner, onnadatta track, birdsville etc.

would only see a max of a 2" suspension lift with all the fruit, and 33" tyres.


discuss?
 
#3 ·
For what your looking for I think you would get better use out of the Leaf rear with the weight your going to carry.


In saying that, I have a coil cab ute set up for touring with a Steel / Canvas Canopy, Water Tank, Sub Tank, Fridge, Full Tool Box and Bed, All with Airbags in the back Coils when loaded and it sits as level as and is SUPER COMFORTABLE!!!!!!!! :cool:

If your after a Long range tourer IMO Comfort is Second to None, might pay a bit more but at the end of a long day on the rough stuff i know which car id prefer to get out of!

Cheers
 
#6 ·
I've got a mate who bought a leaf sprung patrol ute and asking him 'when he's going to convert it coils?' is a running joke, he gets the sh17s pretty quick. So cop'n flak from people about it not being coils would be a con.

They're sprung under too, so they get beached as easier. Leaf sprung vehicles are usually rougher and to make them comfortable you have to loose your weight carrying ability. I personally would spend the extra on a coil cab and get air bags if you need to carry loads regularly.
 
#7 ·
It is a verry simple comparison.

Leaf:
Pro: can carry more weight with the load spread along the chassy.
Con: ruff as guts to drive in.

Coil:
Pro: super comfy, especialy for long distance driving.
Con: cant carry as much weight as the Leaf, But with coil tower bracing is capable of carrying all your turing gear with out fear of failure.


Coil wins hands down in any situation except for somone who is doing short trips carring big loads( big loads been constantly full of sand or bricks.)

Find somone with each if you can, Test drive them both for atleased a 2hr trip and you will see a world of differance.

No matter what you do to leafs they are ruff.
 
#8 ·
I was patient and waited untill a coil cab ute came along, Outback and the others are corect in my opinion as well, 2" lift with std weight springs and bags for when u need to be loaded up.
Comfort on a long trip is king in my book.
 
#10 ·
Before I bought my Patrol wagon I nearly bought a leaf sprung ute and like you I was not 100% sold on leaf springs.

I rang Superior Engineering and they suggested using drop shackles:

http://www.superiorengineering.com.au/product_info.php?products_id=2251

And spacing out the rear wheels as they tend to touch on the chassis rails.

Superior suggested leaf wasn't all bad and could be made to work very well.

However that may be subject to weight carrying ability.

Cheers

Justin