Patrol 4x4 - Nissan Patrol Forum banner

TD42 N/A to Turbo Coversion Questions

51K views 18 replies 12 participants last post by  Mickmike  
#1 · (Edited by Moderator)
Hi all,

I know. Another turbo thread. Before you exit, I wanted to create this as a reference for others looking for this information in one spot. I've spent hours going through the forum, finding answers to some, but not all, of my many questions.

Now I'm no turbo expert, so id like to answer a few common questions plus, id also likes to ask a few more.

For starters. As a baseline, I'm running a 1988 GQ TD42 N/A silver top in the shorty. It's a pig. I'm yet to have her pump tuned as a N/A, but I am looking at having it put off for the purpose of doing a turbo to tune it after the kit is on.

So firstly, questions I know answers to.

Q1. What turbo kit is the best?

A1. There is no perfect kit. There are kits available off the shelf but with so many different vehicles with so many different variables between them. Also, factoring that no two people ever drive the same, nor do they want the car to perform the same, no turbo kit will ever be perfect. But there are some good brands that come close, such as DTS by MTQ, Safari (same as the snorkel brand) and a few others.

Q2. What's the max boost I can run on a silver or blacktop?

A2. Silver tops are stronger in general than black tops. Heavier internals means they can handle more boost. Silver tops can handle in excess of 20psi, and I've heard of people (not proven to me yet) running up to 50psi. But by this stage, the head begins to lift. Black tops are a random jack in the box. I've heard of black tops calling it quits at 5psi and others handling 15psi all day. The general rule, as I can read it, however, is black tops should see no more than 12 to 14 psi.

Q3. What's the biggest boost you can run into a TD42 without an intercooler?

A3. Once again, you will hear a varied number. Mostly its considered 12psi is the limit for non-inter-cooled turbo setups. This is mainly for the engine's longevity and to keep the exhaust temperature down.

Q4. What do you need when upgrading?

A4. The list starts at the turbo, turbo manifold, oil supply lines (depending on the turbo, you could require coolant lines) and a dump pipe to attach an exhaust system.

Q5. Do you have to upgrade your injector pump?

A5. The short answer to this is no. You don't HAVE to. But it's recommended. This is because a non-turbo engine has a non-turbo pump. The difference between them is called a boost compensator. A boost compensator adjusts the fuel-to-air mixture as the turbo spools and provides pressure. So, therefore, more boost = more fuel. Less boost = less fuel. Think of it like your best mate is under the bonnet with a boost gauge and a screwdriver on the fuel screw. You don't have to have a fuel compensated pump. However, if you choose not to, the pump will need to be tuned to provide the fuel it needs at its highest level of boost. So this means if your turbo is set for 15psi and the pump is tuned for 15psi worth of fuel, at 2psi, it still provides 15psi worth of fuel. This causes a major fueling off-peak boost (provided your pump's plunger can provide that amount of fuel).

The other side to this is plunger size. A factory GQ pump (turbo or n/a) is 10mm. There are rumours of late GQ, but definitely, GU factory turbo pumps are 11mm, which can provide enough fuel for up to 20 psi. Any more than this, and you will need a 12mm pump. Bigger than 12mm is very uncommon unless you're chasing huge power.

Q6. How much power can you make from a turbo TD42?

A6. This all comes down to turbo pressure, fuel flow, pump size and condition, engine condition, tyres and rims, as well as exhaust and intake modifications. A lot of factors contribute to the power your engine can produce. So no one can tell you an exact figure. But you can always get a ballpark figure from others dyno sheets from vehicles with similar setups.

Q7. Low mount or high mount turbo?

A7. There is no correct or perfect setup here. A low mount is more concealed and therefore hidden. However, low mount manifolds are costly, and the plumbing is harder. It's also harder to do repairs or maintenance to the turbo. Low mounts also mean they are closer to the ground. Water crossings will mean the turbo hits the water more often on deep crossings. High mounts are easier to set up, plumb and work on. But there are rumours of high mounts heating the firewall easier as well as making it harder to fit a top mount intercooler, depending on your setup. There's a lot to consider here, so a google image search of both gives you some good images to froth over.

Q8. Best exhaust and intake mods

A8. Exhaust, 2.5" or 3" mandrel bent is the go. Stainless lasts longer, but mild steel is cheaper. The different materials also offer different sounds and notes. Intake mods are simple. Throw out the stock airbox, IMO. Its rubbish and square fittings are hard to waterproof. A ZD30 airbox is a common upgrade, and there are even stainless copies of them available from Patrolapart, which work a treat. There are other airbox designs, too; however, some eliminate the option of a secondary battery, and others require a certain snorkel style. Best to do some digging first

Q9. What turbo brand/model is best?

A9. Once again, there are no one size fits. Everyone has their favourite. I personally like the TD05-18G, and others like the GTX2860/2860RS. Two very common turbos, there are a few other brands and models out there, but these seem to be the top two. Depending on where you get it from, many turbo shops can build a turbo for you from a stock form to suit your engine and requirements. They can adjust sizing and flow to make turbos spool at different times and even high flow them for more pressure. Just have a chat with them first about your needs, and they can suggest the right setup for you.

Q10. What's the best way to tune a TD42 after it's been turbo'ed?

A10. You don't. Take it to someone who knows what they are doing at $3k or more for a pump and possibly even more for a rebuild, and you don't want to be messing with your engine setup. Diesel is the particular motor and runs within a tight tolerance. Don't risk it! Unless you're a pro, take it to one!
 
#2 · (Edited by Moderator)
Okay, so now the questions I need to be answered.

I want to test run a low boost turbo setup on my GQ (around 8 to 10 psi) on the stock pump to see how it runs power-wise. Once I get this setup, I then want to put a rebuilt 11mm pump onto the side + an intercooler to run whatever boost I desire in the future.

So my questions are...

1. Has anyone tried this, and were there any major complications? Is it just a matter of piecing it all together and dialing up the fuel and air mixtures until I'm happy? I do know it will run a bit rich off boost, but it's only temporary.

2. Do TD42's generally respond better or worse in fuel consumption with a turbo installed? And at what pressures do people seem to get the best fuel economy? How much fuel are you using at this optimal setting?
The more info we get, the easier it will be to see a solid economic figure! Things like tire size and roof modifications may make differences, too, so mention them if necessary!

3. What power/pressure figures on what clutches are people getting? I currently have a N/A heavy-duty clutch, and I'm worried a low boost setup might be too much. I would definitely look into replacing it with a turbo clutch in the future with more boost, but for now, is this going to hold up?

4. What pressures do people find to be the equilibrium? The best mix of power and economy? Obviously, everyone wants lots of power, but no one wants a big fuel bill. What's your sweet spot? Turbo model, intake and exhaust mods, as well as the cars tires, rims, and roof mods, may also affect this figure, so mention your setup.

If you have any answers to commonly seen or asked turbo questions or if something I have answered is wrong, please contribute! The more resources we have here, the more info there is for everyone.

Cheers 🍺🍻
 
#3 · (Edited by Moderator)
Okay, so now the questions I need to be answered.

I want to test run a low boost turbo setup on my GQ (around 8 to 10 psi) on the stock pump to see how it runs power-wise. Once I get this setup, I then want to put a rebuilt 11mm pump onto the side + an intercooler to run whatever boost I desire in the future.

So my questions are...

1. Has anyone tried this, and were there any major complications? Is it just a matter of piecing it all together and dialing up the fuel and air mixtures until I'm happy? I do know it will run a bit rich off boost, but it's only temporary.
Before you start adjusting the fuel, install an EGT probe and gauge. My GU came with a silvertop and TD05-16G high-mount, no intercooler, and a standard but leaky pump, and running ~14 psi boost. It went a million times better than my silver top NA GQ.
I then switched to a low mount DTS manifold, big intercooler, and DC3 pump, and it now goes a million times better again. Still only running 14 psi, though.
I'm no expert on diesel tuning, but insufficient fuel is better for the engine than too much. Too lean, and it won't make much boost or power. Too much fuel can lead to damage.
So start off with a very small fuel increase, find a hill and see what the EGT gauge does and how quickly it drops back down.
I'm pretty conservative with mine and generally back off before I hit 500*C post turbo.

2. Do TD42's generally respond better or worse in fuel consumption with a turbo installed? And at what pressures do people seem to get the best fuel economy? How much fuel are you using at this optimal setting?
On the highway, my NA GQ with 285s and 4.1 diffs with the 6 of us on board generally sits on 110-115km/h but barely holds 80 up hills, and overtaking only happens downhill. The last time I checked fuel consumption, it was about 15L/100, IIRC.
On the same drive, my GU with 315s and 4.3 diffs and a loaded roof rack is happy to cruise at almost any speed and overtake at will. Boost sits between 5 and 10psi at highway speed, and fuel consumption is about 15L/100. :mrgreen:
I still have to do the injectors and tune the GU, so I may see some further improvements.
Without the 315s and roof rack (and less leadfoot driving), the GU would return even better figures, but I'm not complaining.
 
#4 · (Edited by Moderator)
Typically a turbo upgrade to a TD42 makes very little difference to fuel economy. If anything, there is a slight improvement when adding a turbo to a N/A engine. Adding a bigger turbo and intercooler to a stock turbo motor makes no noticeable difference to the economy. Going with a modified pump can make changes for better or for worse, depending on the pump.

I don't agree with your comment about lean engines burning pistons. The TD42 always runs lean, except for the times it is at full throttle. Even then, a lot of modified engines still run lean because they have nothing left in the pump to keep up with the bigger turbo and cooler.
 
#5 · (Edited by Moderator)
Awesome! Some good info here already.

Another question. I'm looking at a TD05-18G Mamba built turbo. I understand the function of anti-surge turbos and their uses, including being able to spool quickly. However, I also understand they can affect performance once on boost. What's best suited for a low to mid-boost setup on a TD42?

The next question is, what do they sound like? I've heard anti-surge turbos make a whistling noise, and I do love the sound of a turbo TD42 and so does anyone have either one of these that can show me the difference?

Cheers :) 🍻
 
#6 · (Edited by Moderator)
Old Mav has had lots to say about antisurge turbos for the TD42 in the past. If you are lucky, he may see this and chip in. If I remember right, it is to do with running the same boost level over a very wide range of engine revs. A compressor that flows well in the upper rev ranges is likely to surge in the lower rev ranges at the same boost level unless it has antisurge features. Something like that, anyway. An antisurge compressor will always have a slightly lower peak efficiency level than a stock one.

There is minimal turbo noise from my Mamba 16gL; however, it does depend a bit on which compressor wheel you have. The 5+5 and 6+6 wheels are not as quiet as the 11-blade GTX-style wheel. The radiator fan and exhaust both make far more noise than the turbo, both inside the car and out. Youtube might have a clip of a suitable car you can listen to.
 
#7 · (Edited by Moderator)
As you mentioned already, there are no definitive answers to this. An example is that you are looking at Mamba, which costs about $500 from memory. My Borg Warner costs about $2500. So which is better????? Clearly, one will be better in terms of performance, but not for your wallet. Only you can decide that. So the budget is a very big factor.

The other big factor for me is what is your ultimate needs for your engine. Many of us are now on version three of set-ups, and some more than that. Best to avoid that and work out what you want in the end. Buying a 2860RS might be ok with your 10mm pump etc., but if you want more power and torque down the track, then both the pump and turbo will need to be replaced. Not very cost effective. You are better off buying a turbo that can achieve what you need and then adding a pump, manifold, and modified inlets down the track as you can afford them. But don't use something that will have to be removed later. Try and work out your power needs now, and then build to suit. Do it once.
 
#8 · (Edited by Moderator)
Yeah, okay thanks, guys. The mamba I'm looking at is a bit over $1k and is said to be a pretty well built turbo.

If what you're saying about the antisurge turbo's steadily producing pressure through the rev range sounds good for a low boost setup, I would like a constant 10 to 12 psi setup that didn't work too hard. I want reliable and efficient for long trips. Not looking to build a drag car...

At this point, it's a matter of setting the vehicle up as I can afford it. And I reckon a low boost setup on a shorty will go well :)
 
#10 · (Edited by Moderator)
That is an interesting summary, but not all I would agree with.

One is lean burns out pistons. That's totally false. Your diesel runs lean most of the time in the 50+afr. I don't have an AFR meter with that sort of range to tell you how lean our TD gets too. Not enough air for the fuel burns out pistons. Or excessive EMP on ill-matched wheel/turbine housings not allowing enough air back into the cylinder at high combustion pressures...

Low boost setup is an odd terminology to use. For example, on the turbo brand, I have a bias for 10 psi. It has the ability to punch enough lbs/min for 120 to 130 rwkw.s and late 400 early 500 Nm's if you can inject about 90/100cc/1000 shots. And at 26psi has the capacity to do 200 rwkws and 900Nm's with 160cc/1000shots. Same turbo. And again, the same turbo on a N/A tied 10mm pump has done 90rwkw's and 414Nm at 13 psi.

Truly it's not about psi. It's about how much superheated air you can get to the turbine wheel. And how good that turbine wheel/housing combination is to drive your comp wheel fast enough and quick enough to push volume; psi does nothing without volume... On most turbos, psi doesn't always equal volume, either.

It's more about having more than enough air volume to the amount of fuel you have to inject at each rpm, not what psi you are going to aim for. My advice to you on your 10mm or 11mm is to wind up your turbo so you push as much air as you can within the capabilities of your chosen turbo with your limited fuel. Then you will have a fair chance of not burning holes in your pistons. Fuel with not enough air sitting on your piston tops burns holes. It never has too much air, believe me. If you are worried about burning holes in your pistons, pump more air volume in there. Restricting your Cowabunga to 8 psi has a probability with the right fuel to develop holes and over the top EGTs.

As for antisurge holes, you won't need them if you are doing your low boost setup. Antisurge prevention is needed when you have the fuel and push the limits of your turbo.
 
#12 ·
So heres another question for the turbo gods.

Small vs large exhaust housings on turbo's? For expample a TD05-16g 6cm vs 8cm.

And turbo size comparisons, for example a TD05-16G vs TD05-18G?

Am i right to beleive a smaller housing will spool faster but run out of legs quicker. Where as the larger housing spools slower yet lasts longer on boost within the rev range?

And what should people turboing their TD42's be looking for in both engine water temp and exhaust temp? Whats the limits and what is considered safe or stable?

Cheers 🍻

Sent from my SM-G930F using Tapatalk
 
#13 ·
Small vs large exhaust housings on turbo's? For expample a TD05-16g 6cm vs 8cm.
Go for the 6cm exhaust housing regardless of what compressor you are running. At the top end the waste gate is open allowing all the extra flow you need (unless you are well over 200kw).

And turbo size comparisons, for example a TD05-16G vs TD05-18G?
If you are keeping the stock pump then get the 16g. If you are getting a modified pump either now or in the future then get an 18g (or a 20g if you want to get a top shelf intercooler).

Am i right to beleive a smaller housing will spool faster but run out of legs quicker. Where as the larger housing spools slower yet lasts longer on boost within the rev range?
That is the usual story but it needs to be pointed out that the top shelf UFI turbos run a modified 6cm exhaust housing even when matched with a 20g compressor. If you are making enough power to overwhelm the wastegate in a 6cm unit then an 8cm housing might be better but I doubt anyone looking for that much power would be asking these questions.

And what should people turboing their TD42's be looking for in both engine water temp and exhaust temp? Whats the limits and what is considered safe or stable?
For TD42 water temps you should be looking for anything below boiling point.;) EGT post turbo peaks of 600 are supposed to be fine but I'd be happier with 550.
 
#15 ·
You'd be buying a top shelf setup for 5k, you could set up a mid-range kit and cooler for under 3k surely. I tow a 1 tonne plate boat on the standard ht-18 and can hold 120 up most hills on the highway, these puss turbos are going for under a few hundred bucks on gumtree.

Not that I condone selling a patrol, but if you're not doing much decent 4WDing and use it for mainly towing/touring a well set up dual cab may be the way to go.